In insurance claims and civil disputes, the account a person gives of their activities is sometimes central to the outcome. Surveillance can provide an independent, factual record of what was actually observed, so an insurer, solicitor or client can assess the matter on evidence rather than assumption.
Used well, surveillance is focused, proportionate and lawful. Used poorly, it can be intrusive, expensive and of little evidential value. This article explains when surveillance is likely to help in insurance and litigation matters, the legal boundaries that apply and what a useful surveillance report should contain.
When surveillance can assist
Surveillance is most useful when there is a specific question that observation can answer. In insurance and legal matters, that might include:
- Whether a claimant’s day-to-day activities are consistent with the injury or incapacity described in a claim
- Whether a person is working or operating a business while stating otherwise
- Whether a party lives at, or regularly attends, a particular address
- Whether conduct relevant to a dispute, such as a breach of a restraint or an undertaking, is taking place
- Whether property or equipment is being used in the way that has been described
Surveillance is not a fishing expedition. If the question is vague, the observations are likely to be inconclusive. A clear objective, agreed at the outset, is the foundation of a worthwhile assignment.
Starting with the right brief
The more context the investigator has, the better the assignment can be planned. A helpful brief usually includes:
- The background to the claim or dispute and the specific issue in question
- What the person has stated about their activities, limitations or whereabouts
- Relevant addresses, dates and any known routines
- Any timing considerations, such as hearing dates or claim deadlines
- The intended recipient of the report, such as a claims manager or solicitor
With that information, the dates, duration and approach can be planned around when observation is most likely to be useful, which also helps keep costs under control.
The legal and ethical limits
Surveillance in Australia is governed by state and territory legislation, privacy law and, for many insurers, industry codes. The points below are general information only and not legal advice.
Surveillance devices law
In NSW, the Surveillance Devices Act 2007 regulates listening, optical, tracking and data surveillance devices. Among other things, it generally prohibits using a listening device to record a private conversation without the required consent, and using an optical surveillance device where that involves entering premises or a vehicle, or interfering with a vehicle or object, without the consent of the owner or occupier. Other states and territories have their own legislation, and the rules differ.
Insurance industry standards
The General Insurance Code of Practice includes Claims Investigation Standards that subscribing insurers commit to follow. They include requirements for investigations to be limited to the matters that need to be investigated and conducted in an appropriate and respectful manner, as well as specific rules about when surveillance may be authorised. Investigators working for subscribing insurers need to understand and work within those standards.
KEO’s approach
KEO’s experienced investigators observe only what can be lawfully observed, typically activity visible from public places. We do not enter private property without permission, use concealed listening devices to record private conversations, attach tracking devices without the required consent, or approach or deceive the subject to provoke a reaction. Photography and video are obtained only where it is lawful and practicable.
What a useful surveillance report includes
A surveillance report should allow the reader to understand exactly what was observed, when and in what circumstances, without needing to fill in gaps. KEO’s reporting is designed with that in mind.
A chronological written account
Relevant observations are recorded in sequence, with dates, times, locations and the circumstances in which they were made.
Supporting images and footage
Photographs and video of relevant activity are identified and supplied with context, so the material can be understood alongside the written account.
Clear separation of fact and background
The report distinguishes between what the investigator saw and the information supplied at the start of the assignment. Where visibility was obstructed, contact was lost or an observation could not be completed, the report says so.
Fair presentation
Observations should be reported accurately, including activity that may support the subject’s account. A balanced report is more credible and more useful to the decision-maker.
Surveillance as part of a wider enquiry
Surveillance often works best alongside other enquiries, such as background research, document review or witness location. For solicitors, it can form part of broader litigation support. Learn more on our surveillance services page.
Surveillance records only the activity observed during the agreed period. It cannot guarantee that particular conduct will be observed, and the results depend on the circumstances, the subject’s activities and what can be lawfully seen.
Frequently asked questions
How many days of surveillance will a matter need?
It depends on the question to be answered and what is known about the person’s routine. We recommend a plan based on the brief and review it with you as the assignment progresses.
Can surveillance footage be used in proceedings?
Whether material is admissible and how much weight it carries are questions for your solicitor and, ultimately, the court or tribunal. Our role is to obtain material lawfully and report it accurately and in context.
Do you work Australia-wide and internationally?
Provide the location when you enquire. Availability, travel requirements and any interstate or overseas component are assessed before the scope and costs are agreed.
Will the person know they are being observed?
Surveillance is conducted discreetly. Assignments are planned to observe activity without interfering in it.
Need surveillance for a claim or dispute?
Contact KEO Investigations for a confidential discussion about the matter, the question you need answered and the location involved. Scope and fees are agreed before work begins.
Request a confidential consultationCall +61 2 7257 7936
Tower One, 100 Barangaroo Avenue, Barangaroo NSW 2000. Monday to Friday, 9:00 am to 5:00 pm, by appointment.
This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Surveillance laws vary between states and territories. Seek independent legal advice about your circumstances.
