Workplace Investigations: Handling Allegations of Misconduct and Internal Fraud

Quiet glass-walled office meeting room at night with a closed file, notepad and two chairs facing each other under a gold desk lamp

A complaint about a colleague’s behaviour, a payment that does not reconcile or stock that keeps going missing can put an employer in a difficult position. Act too quickly and you risk treating someone unfairly. Do nothing and the problem may grow. A structured workplace investigation helps you establish what actually happened before you decide what to do about it.

This article explains when an independent investigation is worth considering, what a fair process looks like and how KEO Investigations supports employers, HR teams and their legal advisers.

When a workplace investigation may be needed

Not every workplace issue calls for a formal investigation. Many can be resolved through ordinary management. An investigation is usually appropriate when the allegation is serious, the facts are disputed, or the outcome could affect someone’s employment. Common examples include:

  • Allegations of bullying, harassment or other serious misconduct
  • Suspected theft of stock, equipment or other business property
  • Unexplained payments, false invoices or irregular expense claims
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest, such as links between a staff member and a supplier
  • Undisclosed secondary employment or misuse of business resources
  • Suspected misuse of confidential information or client data

Where the concern involves money, it often overlaps with fraud investigations, which follow the relevant transactions and the people or entities connected to them.

Why independence and process matter

How a matter is investigated can be as important as what is found. If an employer later relies on the findings to discipline or dismiss an employee, the process may be scrutinised.

The Fair Work Commission, when considering whether a dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, must take into account matters including whether there was a valid reason related to the person’s capacity or conduct, whether the person was notified of that reason and whether they were given an opportunity to respond. The Commission also explains that the opportunity to respond must come before the decision is made.

An investigation does not make the employment decision. That remains with the employer. But a careful, impartial fact-finding process gives the decision-maker a sound basis and helps show that the matter was handled fairly.

The value of an external investigator

Internal managers may know the people involved, may be witnesses themselves, or may be perceived as having already formed a view. Engaging experienced investigators from outside the business can help with:

  • Impartiality, real and perceived, which supports confidence in the findings
  • Capacity, so managers can keep running the business
  • Confidentiality, by limiting how many people inside the organisation know the details
  • Clear reporting, with findings linked to the evidence behind them

What a fair workplace investigation involves

Every matter is different, but a sound investigation generally follows the same principles.

A clearly defined scope

The investigation should start with specific allegations or questions to be answered. A defined scope keeps the work focused, proportionate and fair to the people involved.

Gathering relevant evidence

Depending on the matter, evidence may include documents, business records, transaction data, witness accounts and, where lawful and appropriate, observations made through surveillance. The approach is chosen according to what needs to be tested, not the other way round.

Hearing from the people involved

Witnesses and the person who is the subject of the allegations should have a proper opportunity to give their account. The person responding should understand the substance of the allegations so they can respond meaningfully.

Findings based on the evidence

The investigator assesses the evidence and makes findings of fact, explaining the reasons for each. Where the evidence does not support a firm conclusion, the report should say so.

Confidentiality throughout

Information should be shared only with those who need it. That protects the people involved and the integrity of the process.

Legal limits to keep in mind

Workplace investigations must stay within the law. In NSW, for example, the Workplace Surveillance Act 2005 generally requires employers to give employees written notice at least 14 days before camera, computer or tracking surveillance of them at work begins, unless an exception or authority applies. Privacy law, surveillance devices legislation and your own policies, contracts and enterprise agreements may also be relevant.

These rules differ between states and territories and depend on the circumstances. This is general information only, so speak with your legal adviser about how they apply to your situation. KEO works within these limits and will not use unlawful methods to obtain information.

How KEO supports employers

  • Explain the matter. Tell us what has been reported or discovered, who is involved and what you need to establish.
  • Agree the assignment. We confirm the objectives, the enquiries proposed, the fees and the reporting requirements before work begins.
  • Conduct the enquiries. Our experienced investigators follow the agreed scope. Anything that affects the direction or cost of further work is discussed with you first.
  • Receive the report. The report sets out the background, the enquiries made, the evidence obtained and the findings, in a form that management, HR or your solicitor can follow and assess.

Where your solicitor is instructing, we can work with them so the report is prepared for their review. Learn more about our corporate investigations.

Frequently asked questions

Should we suspend the employee during the investigation?

That is an employment decision for you and your legal or HR adviser, guided by your policies and the employee’s contract or agreement. We focus on establishing the facts.

How long does a workplace investigation take?

It depends on the number of allegations, witnesses and records involved. We give you an indication when the scope is agreed and keep you informed as the work progresses.

Will the investigator recommend disciplinary action?

Our role is to establish the facts and report findings based on the evidence. Decisions about any action rest with the employer, ideally with appropriate advice.

Can you investigate a suspected internal fraud without alerting the person involved?

In many cases the early stages can be conducted discreetly, for example by reviewing records. Any step involving the person must still follow a fair process. We will discuss the right sequence with you.

Facing an allegation that needs to be investigated properly?

Contact KEO Investigations for a confidential consultation. We will discuss the matter, agree a clear scope and confirm fees before any work begins.

Request a confidential consultationCall +61 2 7257 7936

Tower One, 100 Barangaroo Avenue, Barangaroo NSW 2000. Monday to Friday, 9:00 am to 5:00 pm, by appointment.

This article provides general information only and is not legal or employment advice. Workplace laws vary between jurisdictions and industries. Seek independent legal advice about your circumstances.